Frozen Caramel Pie with a Secret Ingredient!

frozen caramel pie with secret ingredient
Frozen Caramel Pie

My Mother’s Recipe

This is the best recipe for a frozen caramel pie with toasted coconut and pecans and a secret ingredient! It was my mother’s recipe from many years ago. She passed away over 20 years and was making this pie probably ten years before that.

I’m sure it’s not an original recipe but I have no idea of who to attribute it to… I’m giving her the credit.

She was a great cook. My mother and her sisters were always sharing recipes and tweaking them So this recipe could have come from their brainstorming or it could have come from a magazine, cookbook, or newspaper clipping. Who knows. But I’m glad she wrote it down! I want to try my Aunt Mildred’s plain pound cake too one of these days))

I made this pie for Christmas and we finished off the last piece a few nights ago. Carrie loves dessert so I prepared it with her in mind and served it at our Christmas dinner.

Ingredients – Recipe makes 2 Pies

2 Graham Cracker Crusts

1/4 c Butter (1/2 stick)

1/2 c Chopped Pecans

7 oz Flaked Coconut

8 oz Cream Cheese (softened)

1 can Sweetened Condensed Milk

1 1/2 c Sweet Potatoes, Cooked and Mashed

12 oz Caramel Topping

2 8 oz Containers of Cool Whip

Making the Pie

This frozen caramel pie recipe makes two pies. I used prepared graham cracker crusts, but you could use homemade too. Just be sure to let them cool completely.

The first step is to toast the chopped pecans and flaked coconut with 1/4 c butter in a skillet. Start it off with low to medium heat, stirring frequently. Cook until golden brown.

toast coconut and pecans in butter
Toasted Coconut & Pecans in Butter

The coconut and pecan mixture is your “topping.” Set it aside and let it cool completely.

The next step is to create the filling by blending the softened cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk with a mixer. Now comes your SECRET INGREDIENT!

Sweet Potatoes

The sweet potatoes add texture to the filling without a sweet potato taste, but not to my family anyway. The main taste you come away with is a caramel pie with coconut and pecans.

I used canned sweet potatoes. Drain off the liquid and beat until smooth and creamy.

You could also boil sweet potatoes, remove the skins and beat. Just be sure to let them cool completely before assembling the pie. Add the sweet potatoes to the cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk mixture.

beat cream cheese, eagle brand milk and sweet potatoes
The Secret Ingredient!

The last step to the filling is to fold in the two 8 oz containers of Cool Whip. Thaw the Cool Whip in the refrigerator – never in a microwave. Fold in gently. I have never made this recipe with anything but Cool Whip so I can’t say how homemade whipped cream would work. Certainly don’t try whipped cream in a can!

fold in cool whip
Cool Whip

Putting it together.

Spoon some of the filling into each pie crust. I did not measure the amount of filling to add, so use your best judgment. In hindsight, I could have used more filling in my first layer. You could actually measure the filling and divide it out, but it sure seemed like a lot of trouble. So I didn’t.

Sprinkle some of the toasted coconut and pecan mixture over the top of the filling. Drizzle caramel topping on top of the coconut and pecans. I used Hershey’s Caramel Topping. It was a 14 oz jar so I used about 3/4 of it.

spoon filling into pie crusts
Two Pies

Make another layer with filling, toasted coconut, and pecans, and drizzle with caramel topping.

You’re all done and ready for the freezer!

caramel pie for freezer

Cover pies tightly with tinfoil and place in the freezer. Usually, when I use a prepared graham cracker crust, I just wash and place the plastic covering back over the pie, but this frozen caramel pie recipe results in pies being too large for that, so use tinfoil instead.


Serve this pie frozen. It’s fine to leave it out for a few minutes, but I usually cut the pieces and return the pie to the freezer immediately. It keeps well in the freezer for a couple of weeks…..if it lasts that long!

frozen caramel pie
Serve Frozen

Now I need to get back into that notebook of recipes and find Aunt Mildred’s recipe for pound cake! It was absolutely the best. The kind of pound that you could slice off and eat right out of your hand.

You didn’t even need fresh strawberries or canned peaches. But it was good that way too! It was a simple recipe that she baked frequently. Most anytime you stopped by her house…..there was pound cake))))

So stay tuned!

frozen caramel pie secret ingredient
Print Recipe
5 from 1 vote

Frozen Caramel Pie with a Secret Ingredient

This is the BEST recipe for a frozen caramel pie that has toasted coconut and pecans and a secret ingredient! Keep in the freezer and serve it frozen. This recipe makes two pies.
Prep Time30 minutes
Total Time30 minutes
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: caramel sweet potato pie, frozen caramel pie
Servings: 16 Pieces
Calories: 196kcal





  • Add butter, coconut, and pecans to skillet and cook over low to medium heat until nicely browned.
    toast coconut and pecans in butter
  • Remove from heat and allow to cool. Must be cool before adding to pie.


  • Combine softened cream cheese, cooled or room temperature sweet potatoes, and sweetened condensed milk. Beat until smooth.
    beat cream cheese, eagle brand milk and sweet potatoes
  • Fold in whipped topping gently, just enough to blend.
    Fold in Cool Whip

Assemble the Pies

  • Spoon some of the filling into each pie crust.
    spoon filling into pie crusts
  • Sprinkle toasted coconut and pecans over the filling.
  • Drizzle caramel topping over coconut and pecans.
    caramel topping
  • Repeat with another layer of filling, coconut and pecans and caramel topping.
    spoon filling into pie crusts
  • Cover tightly with tin foil and place in freezer.
    caramel pie for freezer

To Serve

  • Serve frozen and return to freezer.
    frozen caramel pie secret ingredient



Serving: 1Piece | Calories: 196kcal | Carbohydrates: 23g | Protein: 3g | Fat: 11g | Saturated Fat: 7g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 1g | Monounsaturated Fat: 3g | Trans Fat: 1g | Cholesterol: 16mg | Sodium: 99mg | Potassium: 194mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 19g | Vitamin A: 1927IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 79mg | Iron: 1mg

More from My Kitchen

Mexican Flan

Strawberry Pie

Easy Caramel Popcorn Balls

Velveeta Pimento Cheese

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *